Transformation of a toxic culture
Transforming “toxic”: moving from judgement to curiosity
Toxic has become a catch-all label for everything we don’t like, don’t understand, or want to avoid. But what we call “toxic” is often just difference, discomfort, or unresolved culture clash. And ironically, labeling someone as “toxic” can actually enable toxic behavior in the name of protecting ourselves.
What if “toxic” wasn’t a hard stop? What if it was an invitation?
We all recognize the feeling: someone in the group makes you tense up. Maybe they talk too much, or speak too directly, or carry an energy that makes you feel on edge. You leave the meeting drained. You want to avoid them. It’s easy to say: they’re toxic.
But here’s the truth: they’re still a person.
What if the problem isn’t the person—but the dynamic?
What if, instead of labeling them as toxic, we got curious about what’s happening in us? What’s being triggered? What values or expectations feel violated?
You don’t have to ignore the discomfort. In fact, you shouldn’t. But if you give it a little space—if you sit with it long enough to ask why —you might find an opening.
That moment of curiosity is where transformation begins.
What’s toxic to one person might be totally normal to another. Maybe it’s a tone, a word choice, a communication style. Maybe it’s someone saying what others won’t. Or maybe it’s simply that they don’t behave the way we expect people to in these spaces.
We have to stop pretending that discomfort equals danger.
For people who don’t feel like they “fit,” being labeled toxic can be a fast track to isolation. Especially for those whose voices haven’t been traditionally welcomed—people of color, LGBTQ+ folks, women, people with different neurotypes or communication styles. If we don’t check ourselves, we can turn “safety” into a new form of exclusion.
The real danger isn’t the person you find difficult. The danger is the culture that forms when boards and organizations avoid the people they don’t understand. When discomfort leads to gossip instead of conversation. When “protecting ourselves” becomes a reason to shut others out.
That’s how “mean girl” dynamics take root—quietly, under the guise of protecting the group.
So what can you do? Start with yourself:
- Avoid labeling people. Instead, become curious. What is making me feel this way? What is being triggered in me?
- Acknowledge how you’re feeling—but pause before reacting.
- Apply that same curiosity to the other person, ask questions instead of making assumptions.
- What are they trying to express?
- What’s behind their urgency, frustration, or silence?
- What support or understanding might they be missing?
Because transforming a toxic culture isn’t about fixing “them.” It’s about showing up differently ourselves.
What’s your experience?
Have you been labeled “toxic”—or labeled someone else that way?
What helped you move through it (or not)?
Let’s start a real conversation.
Use the Toxicity to Transformation Toolbox to help shift your organization’s culture from judgment to curiosity.